BUFFALO, N.Y. - U.S. Attorney James P. Kennedy, Jr.
announced today that Shelby Garigen, 41, of Clarence Center, NY, was charged by
criminal complaint with receipt of child pornography and access with intent to
view child pornography. The charges carry a mandatory minimum penalty of five
years in prison, a maximum of 30 years, and a $250,000 fine.
Assistant U.S. Attorney Aaron J. Mango, who is handling the
case, stated that according to the complaint, on May 28, 2019, a parent
contacted an Assistant District Attorney (ADA) in Monroe County, NY, and
advised that the defendant had inappropriate chats via Snapchat with his
17-year-old son (Victim 1). Garigen had, up until approximately one month
prior, served as the athletic trainer for Victim 1’s elite soccer team, and had
been associated with the soccer program for approximately the past 12 years.
The Monroe County ADA contacted the FBI regarding the case.
The complaint states that Garigen and Victim 1 communicated
via Snapchat between November 2018 and February 2019. The conversation turned
sexual about a week or two after the defendant and Victim 1 began chatting with
Garigen sending Victim 1 a picture of her breasts. After sending the picture,
the defendant requested that Victim 1 send a naked picture. Thereafter, the two
began exchanging sexually explicit photos of themselves to one another over
Snapchat. All told, Garigen requested that Victim 1 send her nude pictures on
approximately 8 or 9 occasions, while the defendant herself sent 7 or 8 nude
pictures of herself.
During the investigation, an undercover investigator assumed
the online identity of Victim 1, and re-engaged with Garigen on Snapchat.
Thereafter, the defendant engaged in sexually explicit conversation and sent
videos of her engaged in sexually explicit conduct. Eventually, arrangements
were made for Garigen to meet with Victim 1 so that the two could engage sexual
activity. On June 14, 2019, Garigen arrived at the designated location in order
to pick-up Victim 1 so that they could return to her house to engage in sexual
activity. At that time, a federal search warrant was executed to seize and
search Garigen’s phone.
The investigation also determined that the defendant
exchanged nude pictures with a second 17-year-old male (Victim 2), who was also
associated with the elite soccer team.
“While this case is somewhat unusual in that the defendant
is a woman,” U.S. Attorney Kennedy observed, “it is familiar in the sense that
defendant used two of the most frequent and common methods that child predators
use in order to gain access to children. The first is the internet, and the
second is occupying a position of authority and trust in the child’s life.
Parents should be coaching their kids on how to defend themselves from these
sorts predators.”
“The exploitation of children is so prevalent in this
country-and around the world-that the FBI and our law enforcement partners have
full time task forces to attack this crime problem,” said FBI Buffalo Special
Agent-in-Charge Gary Loeffert. “That is a terrible reality. We often remind
parents to talk to their children about the dangers of meeting strangers
online. But more and more often, we are seeing children victimized by adults
who have been placed in positions of trust. And youth-sports programs, like all
youth-serving organizations, give adults incredible access to our children.”
The defendant made an initial appearance this afternoon
before U.S. Magistrate Judge Jeremiah J. McCarthy and was released on
conditions, including no employment with any youth related sports program, no
contact with minors, restrictions on the use of electronic devices, and
electronic monitoring.
Any parent or member of the public who has information
related to this case are asked to call the Federal Bureau of Investigation at
716-843-1616.
The complaint is the result of an investigation by the
Federal Bureau of Investigation, Buffalo Division, under the direction of
Special Agent-in-Charge Gary Loeffert, and the Cheektowaga Police Department,
under the direction of Chief David Zack. Additional assistance was provided by
the Monroe County District Attorney’s Office, under the direction of District
Attorney Sandra Doorley.
The fact that a defendant has been charged with a crime is
merely an accusation and the defendant is presumed innocent until and unless
proven guilty.